Italy's Garante fines Meta €805M over default-on Facebook for Android gallery suggestions lacking valid consent; Meta to appeal
Matéria consolidada. Reúne 9 matérias que o Tifon tinha publicado separadamente sobre a mesma história. A IA reescreveu o relatório com o que as 6 fontes trouxeram em 17/11/2026 12:02; os links antigos trazem para cá.
Fontes: malwarebytes.com ↗ gbhackers.com ↗ securityonline.info ↗ securityaffairs.com ↗ thehackernews.com ↗ securityweek.com ↗
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million (about $887 million, per securityweek.com and malwarebytes.com) over the Facebook for Android feature "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook" (rendered "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook" by securityaffairs.com and "camera roll suggestions" by malwarebytes.com). The announcement is dated November 14, 2026 (gbhackers.com). The authority found the feature was enabled by default and accessed photos, videos and metadata of about 20 million Italian Android users without specific, informed consent, through a single, non-specific permission request. This breaches Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code (called the Italian Data Protection Code by malwarebytes.com), which transposes the ePrivacy Directive (thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com). The fine is about 0.47% of Meta's global turnover. Meta calls the fine "disproportionate" and plans to appeal (thehackernews.com, malwarebytes.com); securityonline.info also reports that Meta disputes the findings and plans to appeal. Meta also told Reuters that users must grant device-level permission and can revoke it at any time (securityaffairs.com); malwarebytes.com reports the same position. The violation reportedly continues for users who have not updated the app (securityaffairs.com, malwarebytes.com). This is a privacy enforcement action, not an exploited vulnerability or intrusion, so the direct risk to defenders is limited (securityonline.info, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com, which cites no CVEs). The sources are based on press coverage alone, with no primary-source research, and the Garante's own decision was not checked.
Detalhes técnicos
- The feature suggested personal photos and videos for new posts (securityonline.info). It was enabled by default. Facebook requested gallery access through a single app-wide permission covering several unrelated functions with different purposes (securityweek.com, thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, securityonline.info, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- A general notice appears first (described by securityaffairs.com as a generic "enable other features" prompt; gbhackers.com and malwarebytes.com use the same wording), but it does not make clear that gallery suggestions are also being enabled. securityonline.info describes the pre-permission prompts as vague (thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- A fully granted permission lets the app read the whole photo archive, usually on an ongoing basis. Neither the user nor the authority can verify which data is actually used (thehackernews.com, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- The feature has been available since 2023. The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti (called the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre by securityaffairs.com and the Bolzano Consumer Protection Center by gbhackers.com; securityonline.info speaks of consumer complaints; malwarebytes.com calls it a consumer group) and included the authority's own technical analysis (thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, malwarebytes.com).
- The investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI models, and Meta denies any such use. The Garante may separately examine a newer cloud-processing feature (thehackernews.com, malwarebytes.com), described by securityaffairs.com and gbhackers.com as a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud and is outside this proceeding.
- The Garante rejected Meta's jurisdictional challenge, which argued that Ireland's authority should handle the case, because the ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism (thehackernews.com, securityweek.com, securityaffairs.com, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- Meta argues the feature only works after users grant system-level permissions, which they can revoke in device settings (securityonline.info, malwarebytes.com).
- Factors in the penalty: the number of people affected, the duration of the breach, a 2019 decision against the company, and Meta's limited cooperation ("poor level of cooperation" per malwarebytes.com). Meta's post-complaint changes counted in its favor, but the authority judged them late and limited (thehackernews.com, securityweek.com, securityaffairs.com); malwarebytes.com adds that the changes reached only users who updated the app.
Remediação
- Within 60 days, Meta must disable the feature and request consent through a separate, specific request. The request must explain the feature's purpose, that it accesses the gallery, how the feature processes albums, and how to turn it off (securityweek.com, thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, securityonline.info, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- Within 60 days, the feature must be off by default, including for users who already granted the permission. If Meta misses the deadline, the feature cannot be enabled for anyone without valid consent (thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, gbhackers.com, malwarebytes.com).
- Meta must report on the work it has started within 30 days and on the measures it has taken within 90 days (thehackernews.com, securityaffairs.com, gbhackers.com).
- The Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti advised users to switch off the gallery suggestion settings in the app and to review the app's permissions (thehackernews.com).
- Users can revoke or limit photo access. On Android: Settings > Apps > Facebook > Permissions > Photos and videos. On iPhone: Settings > Privacy & Security > Photos (malwarebytes.com).
Relatos divergentes
- Meta's response: securityweek.com (earlier) said Meta made no immediate comment. thehackernews.com reports that Meta calls the fine "disproportionate" and plans to appeal, and securityonline.info likewise says Meta disputes the findings and plans to appeal. malwarebytes.com (most recent) also reports that Meta calls the fine disproportionate, will appeal, and says users must grant device permission first and can change it in settings. securityaffairs.com cites Meta's statement to Reuters that users must grant device-level permission and can revoke it at any time, and does not mention an appeal. The statements are not contradictory; the appeal plan is attributed to thehackernews.com, securityonline.info and malwarebytes.com.
- Feature name and complainant: thehackernews.com and gbhackers.com give "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook", securityaffairs.com gives "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook", and malwarebytes.com uses "camera roll suggestions". For the complainant, thehackernews.com and malwarebytes.com give the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, securityaffairs.com and gbhackers.com give the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre/Center, and securityonline.info refers only to consumer complaints. These are most likely different renderings of the same feature and complainant, not different facts.
Linha do tempo
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta €805 million over Facebook camera roll suggestions accessing Android users' full photo galleries
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million (about $887 million) for the Facebook "camera roll suggestions" feature on Android. The regulator found that the app obtained access to users' entire galleries through a single, non-specific permission request. It says this breached Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code, which implements the EU ePrivacy Directive. The regulator says the violation is still ongoing for some users, and about 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. Meta says users must grant device permission first and can change it in settings, calls the fine disproportionate and will appeal. This is a privacy and regulatory enforcement story, not a vulnerability or an attack. The article cites no CVEs, and no independent research was done for this record.
Technical Details
- The feature, launched in 2023, was on by default. The permission prompt was preceded by a vague notice ("enable other features") that did not tell users it also enabled camera roll suggestions.
- Full photo access could give the app ongoing access to the whole library, and users could not verify which data was used.
- The investigation began in July 2025 after a report from the consumer group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti. The Garante rejected Meta's request to move the case to Ireland, because the ePrivacy rules at issue do not use that one-stop-shop system.
- The fine reflects the number of people affected, the duration of the violation and Meta's "poor level of cooperation". Meta's app changes came late and reached only users who updated.
- The Garante left open follow-up on possible AI training use, which Meta denies, and on a new cloud processing feature.
Remediation
- The Garante ordered Meta to request separate consent for the feature, with a clear explanation of the data use and how to disable it. Within the 60-day deadline, the feature must be turned off by default, including for users who gave the earlier blanket permission.
- Users can revoke or limit photo access. On Android, go to Settings > Apps > Facebook > Permissions > Photos and videos. On iPhone, go to Settings > Privacy & Security > Photos.
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta €805 million over Facebook Android gallery suggestions accessing photos without valid consent
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's data protection authority (Garante) fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million, according to an announcement dated November 14, 2026. It found that Facebook on Android accessed photos, videos and metadata through the "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook" feature without specific, informed consent. The decision concerns about 20 million Android users in Italy. The case is a privacy and regulatory enforcement matter. The article reports no external attack, public exposure or exploitation. This summary rests on the article alone, because no web research was performed.
Technical Details
- The feature has been available since 2023. The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Center.
- Facebook requested a single authorization covering the whole app and several functions with different purposes. A generic notice asking users to "enable other features" did not make clear that gallery suggestions would also be enabled. The feature was on by default.
- Full permission gave ongoing access to the whole photo archive. Neither users nor investigators could determine exactly what data was used.
- The decision rests on Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which implements the ePrivacy Directive. The authority rejected Meta's argument that Ireland's regulator has jurisdiction, because ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism.
- The ruling does not establish that gallery content trained AI models, which Meta denies. A separate 2026 gallery cloud-processing feature is outside this proceeding.
Remediation
- Within 60 days, Meta must add a distinct consent request that explains the feature's purpose, gallery access and deactivation controls.
- Gallery suggestions must be disabled by default, including for users who previously granted permission. After the deadline, users without valid consent cannot activate the feature.
- Meta must report initial initiatives within 30 days and implement the measures within 90 days.
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million over Facebook for Android gallery scanning without valid consent
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's data protection authority (the Garante) fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million. It found that Facebook for Android accessed users' photos, videos and metadata without valid authorization through its camera roll suggestion feature, introduced in 2023. The investigation opened in July 2025 after consumer complaints. Regulators found that Meta used a single broad application-wide permission across unrelated functions, that the pre-permission prompts were vague, and that the feature was on by default. Meta disputes the findings and plans to appeal. This is a regulatory enforcement action, not a technical vulnerability or active threat. These details come from the article alone. Web research was not performed, so the Garante's own decision was not checked.
Technical Details
- The feature suggested personal photos and videos for new posts.
- The authority found it relied on one broad gallery permission that exposed whole photo libraries.
- Meta argues the feature only works after users grant system-level permissions, which they can revoke in device settings.
Remediation
- Within 60 days, Meta must disable gallery suggestions by default.
- Meta must request separate, explicit user consent.
- Meta must clearly explain how the feature processes albums and how users can turn it off.
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta €805 million over Facebook Android gallery photo-suggestion feature enabled without specific consent
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million. The Facebook app for Android accessed photos, videos and metadata on Italian users' phones through the "Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook" feature, without specific consent and without proper information. The feature has existed since 2023. The investigation began in July 2025 after a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre. Around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, and the violation continues for users who have not updated the app. This is a regulatory and privacy action, not a cyber attack or vulnerability, and it has no direct operational impact on defenders.
Technical Details
- The app requested a single gallery permission that covered several different purposes.
- The authorisation prompt was a generic notice ("enable other features") that did not reveal that it also enabled gallery suggestions.
- The feature was enabled by default.
- The legal basis is Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive. The Garante held that the one-stop-shop mechanism does not apply, so Meta's argument that the Irish authority should handle the case was rejected.
- The case does not address AI training, which Meta denies. The Garante left open a separate review of a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud.
- Meta told Reuters that users must grant device-level permission and can revoke it at any time.
Remediation
- Meta has 60 days to request consent through a separate, specific request and to explain the feature, the gallery access and how to disable it.
- The feature must be off by default, even for users who already agreed.
- If Meta misses the deadline, it cannot activate the feature for anyone without valid consent.
- Meta owes the Garante two reports: one within 30 days and one within 90 days.
- Aggravating factors were the scale, the 2019 fine and limited cooperation. Meta's post-complaint changes were treated as too late.
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta €805 million over Facebook for Android gallery suggestions enabled without explicit consent
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, fined Meta €805 million for the Facebook for Android feature that suggests photos and videos from users' galleries for posting. The authority found the feature was enabled by default. It also found the app accessed photos, videos and metadata of about 20 million Italian Android users without explicit consent, in breach of Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code (the transposition of the ePrivacy Directive). Meta calls the fine "disproportionate" and plans to appeal. This is a privacy and regulatory enforcement action, not an exploited vulnerability or intrusion. The research step was skipped, so the record rests on the article alone.
Technical Details
- The app requests gallery access through a single app-wide permission that covers several functions with different purposes. A general notice appears first, but it does not make clear that gallery suggestions are also being enabled.
- A fully granted permission lets the app read the whole photo archive, usually on an ongoing basis. Neither the user nor the authority can verify which data is actually used.
- The feature has been available since 2023. The investigation began in July 2025, after a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, and included the authority's own technical analysis.
- The investigation did not examine whether gallery content was used to train AI models, and Meta denies any such use. The Garante may separately examine a newer cloud-processing feature.
- The Garante rejected Meta's argument that Ireland's authority should handle the case, because the ePrivacy rules have no one-stop-shop mechanism.
- The fine is about 0.47% of Meta's global revenue. The authority weighed the number of people affected, the duration of the breach, a 2019 decision against the company and limited cooperation. Meta's post-complaint changes counted in its favor, but the authority judged them late and limited.
Remediation
- Within 60 days, Meta must request consent through a separate, specific request for this feature. The request must explain what the feature is for, that it accesses the gallery, and how to turn it off.
- Within 60 days, the feature must be off by default, including for users who already granted the permission. If Meta misses the deadline, the feature cannot be enabled for anyone without valid consent.
- Meta must report on the work it has started within 30 days and on the measures it has taken within 90 days.
- The Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti advised users to switch off the gallery suggestion settings in the app and to review the app's permissions.
-
Italy's Garante fines Meta €805M over default-on Facebook Android gallery suggestion feature lacking valid consent
ler a análise desta fonte ocultar
Italy's Data Protection Authority (Garante) announced a fine of €805 million (about $887 million) against Meta Platforms Ireland Limited. The fine covers the Facebook feature "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook", which used photos and videos from Android users' galleries without specific consent or adequate disclosure. The authority said the practice violated a European privacy directive incorporated into Italian law, which treats smartphones as part of a person's private sphere and requires "free and informed consent". This is a regulatory and privacy enforcement action, not a cyber intrusion, so the immediate risk to defenders is limited. No research on vendor or primary sources was performed; this record is based on the article alone.
Technical Details
- Investigators found the feature was enabled by default.
- Facebook requested gallery access through a single permission that covered several app functions with different purposes.
- Italy has about 20 million Android users, according to the agency.
- Meta challenged Italy's jurisdiction. The authority cited Meta's "lack of cooperation" as a factor in the penalty, which is roughly 0.47% of the group's global turnover.
Remediation
The authority gave Meta 60 days to disable the feature and to seek separate consent for its use. Meta made no immediate comment.